GOVERNMENT CANNOT CLAIM PRIVILEGES IN ARBITRATION MATTERS – Supreme Court of India


The Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (herein after ‘The Act’) with its advent has paved way for an effective alternate dispute resolution mechanism but reduces importance of certain the procedural and other substantive laws that forms the basis of settling disputes before the courts.
The Act focuses on party autonomy where the mutual rights and liabilities emerge out of the contract between the parties at the same time treating all the parties involved alike. The question in this case which perturbs us, as to what is the position when one of the party is the Government? Does the government enjoy any special privilege as it does in the case of suits filed before courts under Civil Procedure Code? This is what exactly was an elaborate point of discussion in Pam Developments Private Ltd.
Vs. State of West Bengal ((2019)8 SCC 112).
As per the Indian law, if a party wishes to challenge the award and get a stay of the enforcement of an award, court shall direct a deposit of a minimum of 80% of the award amount. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the above said case, was faced with a situation where the State of West Bengal had obtained an order of unconditional stay of the award under section 36(2) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 (as amended up to date) after relying on the provisions of Order XXVII Rule 8A of CPC, in the pending proceedings under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act filed in the High Court of Calcutta.
The execution petition filed by Pam Developments Pvt. Ltd.
was also dismissed by the executing court based on an order of a co-ordinate bench of the High Court wherein an unconditional stay of award had been granted to the State Government. Pam Developments, visibly aggrieved, approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Pam Developments assailed the order of unconditional stay on two main grounds (i) The provision of Order XXVII Rule 8A of CPC could not have been applicable and the same should not have been considered while deciding the application for stay of the award under Section 36 of the Arbitration Act. (ii) Even if the provision of Order XXVII Rule 8A is to be taken into account, then too the Courts should not pass an order of unconditional stay of award and could still direct deposit of the awarded amount as security.
It is relevant at this juncture first to see what Order XXVII Rule 8A of the Code of Civil procedure, 1908 says: It says that no such security as is mentioned in rules 5 and 6 of Order XLI shall be required from the Government, for granting stay by the Appellate court or the court which passed the decree. The moot question which came up for consideration was, “whether the Government can be given special treatment/privileges as per the Civil Procedure Code in the Arbitration Proceedings like in civil proceedings before courts”? The Supreme Court while dealing with the said question & analyzing the law w.r.t.
the same, culled out the following:-           The Hon’ble Apex court thus reached the conclusion that unconditional order of stay of the arbitral award could not have been passed by the Calcutta High Court, based on the detailed analysis of the Act, while clearly delineating the position of the Government as it enjoys while being before the Civil court as one of the party and its status under the Arbitration Act. The ratio of this judgment has been able to bind the ethos of the Arbitration Act.
As has been rightly observed by our Hon’ble Apex Court, the seepage of the strict rigours of the Civil Procedure Code in the arbitral proceedings will denude this special Act of its very element of being an “informal & speedier dispute resolution mechanism”. Source: Free Articles from ArticlesFactory.com Author"- S Ravi Shankar & Ruhini Dey  .

Top blog stories

A review of Idmobile.com

Idmobile.com offers both pay-as-you-go and contract plans. Pay-as-you-go plans are ideal for customers who don't want to be tied down to a long-term contract, and they can purchase bundles of data, minutes, and texts as and when they need them.

see post

A review of Idmobile.com

Idmobile.com offers both pay-as-you-go and contract plans. Pay-as-you-go plans are ideal for customers who don't want to be tied down to a long-term contract, and they can purchase bundles of data, minutes, and texts as and when they need them.

see post

AO.co: Online Shopping Made Simple

AO.co is a trusted expert in TVs, washing machines, clothes dryers and other household appliances. AO.com is one of the largest retailers in the UK and it specializes in electronics, clothes and home furniture.

see post

For our people.

At Three, we believe phones are good. They just make life better. Easier. And more fun. But we all need to find a balance that works for us. Our mission is to help our customers use their phones to live their best lives.

see post

We make your life easier

We make your life easier Since 1992, we’ve been helping customers get the best deal on their dream phone. We firmly believe in giving you the highest quality, for the lowest price. That’s why we work with three of the UK’s leading networks to do all the haggling for you,...

see post

FOUR BRANDS BECOME ONE. CURRYS.

Currys PLC is a leading omnichannel retailer of technology products and services, operating through 800+ stores and 16 websites in seven countries.

see post

Halfords - Quicker, Easier, and Convenient.

At Halfords, we're all about the journey. With more than 700 stores with over 10,000 colleagues, we're the UK's leading retailer of automotive and cycling products. We are also the leading operator in MOT, tyres, car servicing and car repairs - pleasing more than 750,000 customers every year.

see post

FOUR BRANDS BECOME ONE. CURRYS.

Currys PLC is a leading omnichannel retailer of technology products and services, operating through 800+ stores and 16 websites in seven countries.

see post

Sky - Epic. Endless. Entertainment.

It's important to us that everyone gets great customer service and can enjoy our products, no matter their level of sight. So, if you're blind, partially sighted or struggle to see or read the screen, we’ve a range of features to help you get the most from our products and...

see post

Nasty Gal - We exist for the “girl in progress”.

Look iconic, without the hassle— using Nasty Gal discount codes, you can shop your favorite pieces for way less by simply entering one of our promotional codes (of your choice) at the checkout. From delivery offers, to promo deals, we keep ‘em coming, so you always have the offer you...

see post

Digital Publishing From Past to Now

The Covid-19 has caused the school and universities to shut down around the world creating a major issue in Learning and Education. As this virus spreads through the interaction and if social distanci... The Covid-19 has caused the school and universities to shut down around the world creating a major...

see post

Why it’s Important to Manage Your Holiday Calendars?

A printable calendar 2021 is a prominent online platform where you download printable calendars of your choice. These calendars can be customized as per our client requirement with photo, text, logo, or any other image. If you are thinking of planning a dream vacation tour with family and kids but...

see post

How To Pick A Women's Robe


A ladies sleepwear basic, the women's robe is an essential lingerie style. The majority of women have at least a couple of robes in their wardrobe. But there is so much more to this favorite lingerie style than velour or cotton robes. The women’s robe has become a must have...

How Do I?


0 false 18 pt 18 pt 0 0 false false false /* Style Definitions */ ... HOW DO I? By Jr Davis [email protected]`   How Do I?  Almost everyday of my life, not soon after waking up this is the first question I ask myself. How do I get everything done...

When to Divorce a Narcissistic Man -- The Fastest Divorce is Never the Easiest Divorce


"How will I know when to divorce and finally find freedom for myself and the kids?" you ask yourself again and again.  "How can I get this nightmare behind me and just get the fastest divorce possible... Source: Free Articles from ArticlesFactory.com

The Handy And Cost Effective Solutions For Not Smiling


Have you stopped smiling due to the poor discolouration of your teeth, uneven length or wide gaps in your mouth? If this is you, shout with joy as you no longer need to suffer with these problems now that Dental Veneers are available. Discover the advances and cost savings now...

Do Not Lose Your Domain Name to a Shady Web Design Firm


This article is addressing one simple but very important question to ask; who will own my domain name? Registering a domain name is one of the very first steps in the web design process and it is one of the most common services that is taken for granted. Part of...

Teeth Whitening - Is it Enough?


Teeth Whitening is the big buzz at the moment but is it good for you? After treatment some people suffer from Sensitive Teeth and Gum irritations. Did you also know that if you have Crowns or Veneers they will not change colour like your natural teeth? There is a better...

Search topic

Teeth Whitening - Is it Enough?

Teeth Whitening is the big buzz at the moment but is it good for you? After treatment some people suffer from Sensitive Teeth and Gum irritations. Did you also know that if you have Crowns or Veneers they will not change colour like your natural teeth? There is a better...

Learn more