ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE OF ELECTRONIC RECORD IN INDIA
By a recent Judgement dated 14.07.2020, the Supreme Court of India while deciding Arjun PanditRao Khotkar[1] settled the law relating to admissibility of evidence of electronic records in legal proceedings. [1] Arjun Panditrao Khotkar Vs Kailash Kushan Rao Gorantyal and others, (2020) SCCOnline SC 571 Above said judgement was delivered by a three-judge bench comprising of Hon’ble Justices Mr R.F. Nariman, Mr S. Ravindra Bhatt and Mr V. Ramasubramanian JJ dealing with the interpretation of Section 65B of the Evidence Act[1]. The said bench was formed to decide the correctness of the judgement of the Supreme Court of India in Shafhi Mohammad Case[2] in the light of a judgement given by a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court in Anvar P V Case[3]. The above said sec 65B of the Evidence Act was introduced 20 years ago by an Act 21 of 2000 is neither in line with the development of technology nor in line with the major jurisdictions of the world, was the comment of Justice V. Ramasubramanian who wrote a supplementary judgement, even though he concurred with the majority view. As a matter of practice, genuineness, veracity or reliability of the evidence is seen by the court only after the stage of relevancy and admissibility. Hence, one of the principle issues that arise in a court proceeding is the nature and manner of electronic records in a court proceeding. This becomes important in view of section 22 A of the Evidence Act that reads that oral admissions to the contents of electronic records are not relevant, unless the genuineness of the electronic record produced is in question. Moreover, section 59 under part II of Evidence Act dealing with proof reads that all facts, except the contents of the documents or electronic records, may be proved by oral evidence. More importantly section 65A of the Evidence Act reads that the contents of electronic records may be proved in accordance with the provisions of section 65B. Section 65B of the Evidence Act states that any information contained in the electronic record shall be deemed to be a document without further proof or production of the original as an admissible evidence. In 65B(2) it explains certain conditions that are required to be fulfilled, to make the electronic record as an admissible evidence which include that the record is produced from the computer which was used to store and process the information by the person having lawful control over the computer in the course of regular business activities, during the said period the said device was operating properly, the information contained in the electronic record is derived from such information fed into the computer etc., In addition to that the person occupying a responsible official position in relation to the operation of the relevant device should certify certain aspects under Section 65B(4) of the Evidence Act. For the convenience the said section is reproduced below- “(4) In any proceedings where it is desired to give a statement in evidence by virtue of this section, a certificate doping any of the following things, that is to say – (a) identifying the electronic record containing the statement and describing the manner in which it was produced; (b) giving such particulars of any device involved in the production of that electronic record as may be appropriate for the purpose of showing that the electronic record was produced by a computer; (c) dealing with any of the matters to which the conditions mentioned in sub-section (2) relate, And purporting to be signed by a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to the operation of the relevant device or the management of the relevant activities (whichever is appropriate) shall be evidence of any manner stated in the certificate; and for the purposes of this sub-section it shall be sufficient for a matter to be stated to the best of the knowledge and belief of the person of stating it. ” The main issue covered in the article is whether the above said certificate under section 65B (4) is mandatory or not for the purpose of admissibility of an Electronic record as an evidence. In the case of Anvar P V (Supra) the Court held that 65B(4) certificate by the competent person is mandatory requirement for admissibility of an electronic record as an evidence. It further held that the person who certifies only needs to state that the certificate that the same is to the best of his knowledge and belief. Most importantly the said certificate should accompany the electronic record like Computer Printout, Compact Disc(CD), Video Compact Disc(VCD), Pen drive etc., pertaining to which a statement sought to be given in evidence, when the same is produced in evidence. It further stated that only if the electronic evidence is duly produced in terms of Section 65B of the Evidence Act, would the question arise as to the genuineness thereof and in that situation, resort can be made to Section 45-A, opinion of Examiner of Electronic Evidence. It further held that the Evidence Act does not contemplate or permit the proof of an Electronic record by an oral evidence if requirements under Section 65B of the Evidence Act are not complied with as the law now stands in India. Later various judgments including Shafhi Mohamad(Supra) held that the applicability of procedural requirement under section 65B(4) of the Evidence Act of furnishing certificate is to be applied only when such electronic evidence is produced by a person who is in a position to produce such certificates being in control of the said device and not of the opposite party. It was further held that in a case where electronic evidence is produced by a party who is not in possession of a device, such party cannot be required to produce certificate under section 65B(4) of the Evidence Act. It was further held that the applicability of requirement of the said certificate being procedural it can be relaxed by the Court whenever interest of justice so justifies. But in the above said Arjun Panditrao (Supra), the Supreme Court of India settled the law by overruling Shafhi Mohammad (Supra) and declaring Tomaso judgement[4] of the Supreme Court of India and upheld Anvar PV (Supra) with one alteration in paragraph 24 by deleting the words “under section 62 of the Evidence Act”. Hence, the law as on today with regard to admissibility of electronic record as evidence can be summarized as follows: Indian Arbitration Act[5] expressly excludes the applicability of Evidence Act to the arbitration proceedings and hence the above said requirement of filing a certificate under section 65B(4) does not arise with regard to electronic records produced as evidence in an arbitration proceeding. [1] Indian Evidence Act,1872 [2] Shafhi Mohammad Vs State of Himachal Pradesh, (2018) 2 SCC 801 [3] Anvar PV Vs PK Bhaseer , (2014) 10 SCC 473 [4] Tomaso Bruno Vs State of UP, (2015) 7 SCC 178 [5] Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Source: Free Articles from ArticlesFactory.com S. Ravi Shankar the Managing Partner of the Firm, is one of the leading arbitration lawyers of India having a strong International and Domestic exposure. He is an expert Arbitration lawyer handling International and Domestic arbitrations in the fields of Construction and Infrastructure, Investment and Joint venture, International and Domestic supply contracts, Service contracts, Oil and gas supply contracts etc., He is also a qualified Advocate on Record in the Supreme Court of India, with more than 25 years of Experience in the field of law..
Top blog stories
A review of Idmobile.com
Idmobile.com offers both pay-as-you-go and contract plans. Pay-as-you-go plans are ideal for customers who don't want to be tied down to a long-term contract, and they can purchase bundles of data, minutes, and texts as and when they need them.
Idmobile.com offers both pay-as-you-go and contract plans. Pay-as-you-go plans are ideal for customers who don't want to be tied down to a long-term contract, and they can purchase bundles of data, minutes, and texts as and when they need them.
AO.co is a trusted expert in TVs, washing machines, clothes dryers and other household appliances. AO.com is one of the largest retailers in the UK and it specializes in electronics, clothes and home furniture.
At Three, we believe phones are good. They just make life better. Easier. And more fun. But
we all need to find a balance that works for us. Our mission is to help our customers use
their phones to live their best lives.
We make your life easier
Since 1992, we’ve been helping customers get the best deal on their dream phone. We firmly believe in giving you the highest quality, for the lowest price. That’s why we work with three of the UK’s leading networks to do all the haggling for you,...
At Halfords, we're all about the journey. With more than 700 stores with over 10,000 colleagues, we're the UK's leading retailer of automotive and cycling products. We are also the leading operator in MOT, tyres, car servicing and car repairs - pleasing more than 750,000 customers every year.
It's important to us that everyone gets great customer service and can enjoy our products, no matter their level of sight. So, if you're blind, partially sighted or struggle to see or read the screen, we’ve a range of features to help you get the most from our products and...
Look iconic, without the hassle— using Nasty Gal discount codes, you can shop your favorite pieces for way less by simply entering one of our promotional codes (of your choice) at the checkout. From delivery offers, to promo deals, we keep ‘em coming, so you always have the offer you...
The Covid-19 has caused the school and universities to shut down around the world creating a major issue in Learning and Education. As this virus spreads through the interaction and if social distanci... The Covid-19 has caused the school and universities to shut down around the world creating a major...
Why its Important to Manage Your Holiday Calendars?
A printable calendar 2021 is a prominent online platform where you download printable calendars of your choice. These calendars can be customized as per our client requirement with photo, text, logo, or any other image. If you are thinking of planning a dream vacation tour with family and kids but...
Flannel sleepwear is without a doubt one of the most popular ladies sleepwear styles. But do you have any idea what it is exactly? What it is made of? Flannel sleepwear is just one of the many ladies sleepwear styles that are popular today. But do you have any idea...
You have to tackle the challenges that face you by adopting and applying things that work well towards the attainment of your personal goals. A habitual development assists you when trying to achieve goals. Article Tags: Personal Goals, Habitual Developments Source: Free Articles from ArticlesFactory.com
What is your main concern when it comes to buying skin care? For many it is knowing what to buy in the first place and do you go for a brand or something cheap? Botanical extracts are all the rage in beauty and skin care products, and for good reason....
There are a vast range of acne products that are available on the market. Obviously you want to be able to ensure that what you buy will help to clear your skin without any harsh side-effects. There are several natural supplements for acne that could help reduce pimples. If you...
Discover the fast, cost affective and long lasting solution to your Cosmetic Dentistry needs. No longer do you need to suffer silently with Teeth that have Worn Enamel or are showing excessive Wear and Tear. Stained Teeth can now also be a thing of the past with the Glamsmile Porcelain...
Women's robes are without a doubt one of the most useful ladies sleepwear styles available today. From refined and worldly to fresh and provocative, there are umpteenth varieties of robes in stock that suit virtually every taste and need. Here we will take a look at some of the more...
For example, most restaurants-especially national franchises have their own website and and allows you to sign up as a member to their website and you get emails that alert you about special deals going on at their restaurant. Source: Free Articles from ArticlesFactory.com
We hear our dentist say Dental Implants and we shiver in fear. This is always due to not understanding the procedure. Once you discover the truth about things such as Technological advances, Procedures required, Time needed for it all and the stunning realistically looking results you will change your mind...
By Anthony Ricigliano - News And Advice by Anthony Ricigliano -- The study of coins, also known as numismatics, has its origins going back to the first exchange of the metal discs for the purpose of commerce. While still hotly debated, its likely that the first coin was minted circa...
These days, there is a great variety of brassiere alternatives. Great styles include everything from full bras and minimizer bras to push up bras and demi cup bras, the choice goes on and on! It can be awe-inspiring trying to determine the different bra styles. The essential thing to bear...
Search topic
Choosing Full Bras
These days, there is a great variety of brassiere alternatives. Great styles include everything from full bras and minimizer bras to push up bras and demi cup bras, the choice goes on and on! It can be awe-inspiring trying to determine the different bra styles. The essential thing to bear...